The Effort of Blame: Bushfires and Burnt Koalas.

14 comments

Sun at 4

I have meteoranxiety. The red, orange and yellow colours on the satellite weather screen indicate the intensity of precipitation. Yellow is moderate, red is heavy rain. I am being teased by the rain. Only the top of my head is wet but the most savage drought I have experienced in my lifetime (I am 66) may be ending. All around, thunderstorms are delivering deluges, but some give nothing but dry lightning. A fire or a flood? The Earth emotions of it all; ‘delugenvy’ as I am jealous of people and places getting heavy rain only a few kilometres away when I get nothing; what I crave is ‘tinpany’, the rhythmical drumming of constant, hard rain on a metal roof. The depth markers on my water tanks are getting lower every day. My solar panels are filthy.

Every so often the clouds lift and the sun shines on the Friedensreich Hundertwasser landscape. The artist taught me that only after rain and when the sun shines, do the true colours in a rain-washed landscape get revealed. As the patina of red dust and dirty ash is removed, I finally get to see with clarity what the drought has done to Wallaby Farm … forests have turned Northern Hemisphere autumnal due to the death drought. Maple reds, orange and yellow reveal the colours of life bleeding from evergreen eucalypt forests. Yellow is sunburnt, red is intense loss of life.

My region looks like a bush fire has been through it. At a glance, some trees look as though they are actually on fire. Whole ridgetops are stained dead leaf brown. I want the dilute sun to go away. I prefer the night when I cannot see the dead and dying trees. However, even at night I know something is uncanny. There is something new in the soundscape, the constant jostling of dead, dry leaves. Death rattles. I am rattled.

The sun has not been fully present for weeks now. The bushfires, so huge in extent and so intense as they raze the forests, have blotted out the sun with thick, acrid smoke. In some places, day has turned into night. In others, the colour of the sky is … burnt orange. The normal blinding rays of the sun have been rendered harmless by a cataract that has covered half of Australia and my eyes.

People now openly talk about the recent fires as ‘apocalyptic’ (meaning massively destructive) and it is worthwhile remembering what this word means and where an association with fire comes from. The Greek word ‘apokalupsis’ (apocalypse) means both disclosure and a revelation. The Book of Revelations in The Bible is actually a book about the divine foretelling of disasters that befall sinful humans on Earth.

In ‘Revelations’ there are many references to the power of God via his angels to use fire to destroy all life. An angel allowed fire and smoke that turned the sun and the sky black to issue forth from the bottomless pit of a great furnace. Forests and green things were wiped out by “hail and fire mingled with blood”, and then, if that was not enough, human sinners were killed “… by the fire, and by the smoke, and by the brimstone”.

Australia has become a ‘book’ of revelations in that the fires have disclosed or revealed the powerful impacts of global warming to all who have been touched by the fire, smoke and brimstone. The combination of record heat, a record drought and strong winds have produced ‘unprecedented’ wildfire. The bottomless pit has turned out to be global warming.

While wild fire in the past has killed many more people, (Black Friday (1939), Ash Wednesday (1983), Black Saturday (2009)), the hyper-fires of the spring-summer of 2019-2020 in Eastern Australia wiped out over 18 million hectares (46 million acres) of forest, farmland and settlements. Millions of Australians have been directly or indirectly (friends and relatives) impacted by the fires.

Ecologists estimate that over one billion vertebrate animals have perished and clearly, trillions of invertebrates were consumed by the fires. Nothing on this scale and ferocity has happened before in the last 300 years, even in Australia, a land well-used to fire. The economic cost of these events will be in the billions and the restorative efforts will be ongoing and may not be successful as a new abnormal landscape emerges.

As part of the ongoing ‘revelation’ produced by the fires, there is the political fallout where, for decades, government inaction has been driven by denial of the basic scientific facts on climate warming. The political system has been corrupted by the influence of the fossil fuel industry to such an extent that it no longer represents the interests of the people of Australia. Politics no longer governs, it is governed.

The ‘closed system’ of lobbyists, senior executive corporate managers, private think tank researchers, retiring politicians, senior public servants and the members of boards of directors in large corporations have all become interchangeable. Their sole purpose is to maximise corporate shareholder profits (and their own) via donations to political parties, usurpation of the role of policy making, influencing election outcomes via social media, sowing ‘doubt’ about science in mainstream media and the old-fashioned forms of influence via brown paper bags full of money.

So bad is the corruption, I have called it ‘corrumpalism’ after the Latin ‘corrumpere‘ to destroy. While achieving success at maximizing corporate profit, the fossil fuel industry in particular, destroys the biophysical foundations of all life on Earth. Ecocide is preferred over threats to profit.

After the fires have been extinguished by firefighters and rain, perhaps the public of Australia, and indeed, the rest of the world, are ready to accept the horrible truth about global warming?

Many, myself included, have unleashed anger about this state of affairs to blame the politicians for not acting on the science. My ‘terrafurie’ (Earth anger) has found a worthy target. On the left and the right, Australia’s politicians and their climate policies have been an unmitigated disaster. They have even been called out at international fora by nations already suffering discernible impacts from climate warming (e.g., sea level rise). However, in analysing my anger, I have come to the realisation that the blame game must go further. We must dig deeper into the psyche for what is really happening to our emotional compass.

The emotional and psychological toll of the fires on humans has been enormous and many are still coming to terms with their raw personal reactions. So too are the mental health professionals who deal with the emotions and feelings people are experiencing. There are the standard diagnostic categories that apply to people who experience trauma and loss, but over and above that, there are new, uneasy feelings connected to a malevolent cause. Nobody knows what to do.

Our response to distress in the non-human, while perhaps novel because of the scale of the disaster that has affected our wildlife, is consistent with our fine traditions of caring for the non-human that have developed over the last 50 years. WIRES and other caring organisations and their army of volunteers have shown us and people all over the world, that we care for the non-human.

When the Koalas scream in pain in the wildfires, we all hurt and feel the tierratrauma. When images of burnt Kangaroos on barbed wire are graphically presented to us, we all grieve. Film and photography of the non-human fire victims force us to bear witness to that which we would normally evade or ignore. Despite that, many still do not want to see these images of death.

The same applies to the human element of the death and injury caused by the fires. There is an understandable lack of openness when it comes to the human toll in fire. We ‘list’ the people who burn to death, but social convention hides their death from public eyes. We watch the mourning and ritual associated with the victim’s loved ones but we do not want to get too close. It is too confronting and we do not wish to invade the privacy of others.

The confrontation with the horror of fire in both humans and non-humans has not, as far as I can discern, given rise to a deeper level of analysis that addresses the evasion of our own roles in creating the conditions of catastrophe. We have ‘externalised’ the fires and failed to acknowledge our own complicity in their origin and impacts.

What I think is needed for the Australian psyche is a confrontation with that which has been avoided for many decades now … a confrontation with ourselves. We seem willing to blame everyone and everything else for the death and destruction, except ourselves.

I had insight into this ‘failure’ when developing the concept of solastalgia. A classic case study in the lived experience of environmental desolation is the salt-affected areas of the wheatbelt of Southern WA. As a result of over-clearing the native vegetation, ancient salt layers have risen to the soil surface, lifted by a rise in the water-table. The water table has risen because there are no longer trees acting as landscape pumps transpiring the water back into the atmosphere. Salt rises.

By mass clearing of trees, dryland salinity is an environmental problem directly caused by human agency. I went to this area while based in WA and asked land holders how they felt about the emergence of this land degradation. Many said that although it was their own grandfathers who were responsible for clearing the land, they still felt a layer of guilt for what had happened to once productive paddocks and the once healthy ecosystem that was in situ before it was cleared. A sublimated additional emotional awareness was their knowledge of the salt rubbed into the wounds of the Indigenous owners of that place. They cared for that country for over 60,000 years – the colonists had rendered it lifeless in less than 200.

The solastalgia, the distressing lived experience of the collapse of their own farm land and its health, is heightened by the known historical culpability of those who live on that land and have been responsible for managing it. They caused their own dry land salinity and with it the extinction of vitality. The grief of solastalgia is sharpened by the knowledge of their own ecocide.

In the mega-bushfires there is a similar narrative that needs to be unpacked. Although I will focus on the areas most devastated by the recent bushfires, I wish to make it clear that my analysis is one that could be applied anywhere in Tasmania, Eastern, Southern and SW Australia in any location badly affected by wildfire.

The holidays for eastern Australians in the High Country, camping near the idyllic beaches, national parks or Kangaroo Island, are not at all like clearing the ‘wheatbelt’ with bulldozers and big chains. However, there is a big metaphorical bulldozer hard at work achieving much the same result in natural landscapes that have survived because of their exceptional beauty, flood risks or sheer ruggedness. It is no surprise to learn that most our national parks and uncleared land are in areas where clearing for agriculture is not viable. Too steep for bulldozers, too steep for firefighting.

Since the introduction of cheap cars and petrol in the 1950s, these areas have become like Mecca for tourists and holiday makers. The guests pour out of the cities in jets, ferries, SUVs, camper vans and caravans and cars filled to the brim with all mod cons. Caravans are now expensive condos on wheels. Everything is powered by fossil fuels and the carbon footprint to go ‘on holidays’ is enormous. Not that each family holiday has contributed much to the national greenhouse gas quotient, but their cumulative impact is like that of an out of control bushfire.

Those who choose to live in these loved places are all ‘making a living’ by resource extraction, agriculture, tourism and the service industries needed to meet human needs. Kangaroo Island, for example, before the fires, was home to extensive forest industries. The island had become a major international and national tourist destination. It was going gangbusters with plans for a new port for woodchips, drilling for lithium and other rare metals. Kangaroo Island represents a miniature version of Australia island in that under the forces of global development and climate warming, no island is an island.

The bushfires that forced thousands to evacuate their holiday places were fueled by dry vegetation. So important was the concept of ‘fuel’ that some pyromaniacs even suggested that we should eliminate all fuel in fire prone areas so as to totally eliminate the risk of wild fire. Of course, that would mean the defoliation of the very places where people go ‘bush’ to have their holidays. It erases the very possibility of water catchment areas for natural rainfall and runoff into our dams. Wild and managed forests for timber products become too risky and they too must go. We eliminate the essence of wild eastern Australia and an endemic sense of place. Goodbye Lyrebirds, we will miss your imitation of fire alarms.

The ultra-dry vegetation was present mainly because of a hyper-drought. Over the last two years, a savage drought had sucked the moisture out of landscapes and dams. The area that burned was like tinder; one cigarette butt, one bolt of lightning and all hell breaks loose. Layered on top of the record drought was record heat in the late spring and early summer of November and December 2019 in most of South Eastern Australia.

The record heat was present because global warming has inexorably made every place on the planet hotter than in the past. Australia was experiencing record heat waves and record maximum temperatures. The chance of catastrophic wildfire was an outcome of multiple risk factors all coinciding with maximum intensity. The ancient three elements, earth, wind and water, all conspired to give birth to the fourth … fire.

The scientific explanation for the record heat lies in the relentless emissions of greenhouse gases into the global atmosphere, particularly in the last 50 years. These gases, like a blanket, warm the world. The direct cause of the increasing greenhouse gases is the burning and exploding of carbon-based energy (fuel) in every internal combustion engine and furnace in the world. The coal-fired power stations, the billion or so vehicles (cars and trucks) the jets, running the internet, air conditioners and fossil-fuelled agriculture (meat and plant based) are all implicated in the complex causality of the problem.

The people of Eastern Australia are no different than people in other parts of the developed world. They are contributing to this problem with every aspect of their lifestyle. However, Australians do have one of the highest per-person carbon footprints of any people on the Earth and it just keeps getting larger, along with our SUVs and houses.

There we have it, the ‘wild’ in fire is now anthropogenic (human caused) and by every single person living a normal lifestyle in contemporary Australia. No longer can we blame ‘others’ for our own failings and sins. It does not even make sense to blame politicians since ‘we’ keep voting parties into power that have no effective policy with respect to the mitigation of climate warming in the form of divestment from the fossil fuel industries.

The book of revelations is the book of the apocalypse, however, this time it is not God, ‘his’ angels nor the four horsemen who are responsible for this inferno. While not all are equally to blame for the predicament we are in (our children, for example), responsible adults must look into the mirror and ask who without carbon sin will caste the first brimstone?

The mirror image of ourselves offers a stark revelation about our own culpability with respect to the real cause of the wildfires. Each one of us must accept some blame and respond. Such a revelation is transformational. We can shift from feeling anxiety, or anger or a desire to blame, into deep mitigation and the elimination of a carbon-based economy. Our personal lives, our patterns of consumption, what we demand of our politicians and those in other countries must now align with ethical and practical precision in the elimination of excess greenhouse gases from our lives. The politics of corrumpalism must end. The evasion about real causes must be exposed. Who tried to kill the Koalas? We did.

 

 

 

14 comments on “The Effort of Blame: Bushfires and Burnt Koalas.”

  1. Thank you Glenn for your “unpacking” and your understanding of this complex situation. I agree with you in many respects. I have been observing the situation with government’s lobbyists for decades and unless something changes there, there will be no movement in the positive direction. Perhaps people lost trust in government to a certain degree now, but I can see that there continues to be a great gap between people’s understanding about what is the role of governments and what the governments actually do. If they did something different the country would have been better prepared for such a situation. Wait til next year’s repeat of this scenario and what government’s will be saying then. You talk about corruption – yes corruption and lies. The question is who benefits from this situation. Some people will never have to run for their lives to escape fire – just “follow the money”!

    Like

  2. It is really hard to see “through” the reality if we are born into it and lead a comfortable life. This reality is normal. One must find oneself outside of the normal to see the reality from a different lens. People choose reality they want to live in.

    Like

  3. Glenn, as I read your article I was nodding my head in agreement. I also have felt the pain and grief of watching a loved landscape wither and succumb to a grinding drought. Many of the trees, including one massive old sentinel iron bark that used to be the guiding landmark, have died in the drought and subsequent bush fire. The bush remained that way, stuck in a stasis of ash and burnt trunks, until good rain fell. Now we see the beginnings of new shoots, and with that our spirits lift and we start to harbor hope again.
    But we know this is part of the bigger change. We know we are entering the 6th mass extinction and it has a terrible effect on our thoughts. Our optimism is dashed, we worry for our children, we feel a sense of desolation when we consider the species which will become extinct.
    So then, do my individual actions make any difference? I do put out water for birds and kangaroos. This year the roos and a gorgeous pretty faced wallaby ate my vineyard, but I let them, because they were starving. I try to grow at least some of my own food, I have solar panels, I am on tank water and I try not to drive every day. However, it is not enough. Individual efforts have not been enough.
    And this is where I think your analysis is a little unfair, because if I could choose an alternative and affordable way to live that had minimal impact on the planet, I would do so. But I cannot afford an electric car, and even if I could there are no places to charge it up. So then, I won’t drive, but there’s no public transport where I live and I become a hermit because I don’t interact with people. All of that lack of infrastructure is not any of my doing. It is, in fact, a failing of the system, a system based around the pleasures of the internal combustion engine and the availability of cheap, reliable power. But it’s not like I have been presented with a viable option.

    Like

    1. Thanks for your comment Philippa. Like you, I was born into a world I did not create. The ‘great acceleration’ of the Anthropocene has taken place during my 66 years of life. Knowing, like you, that the Anthropocene is ecocidal, I have been doing exactly as you have, investing my retirement into renewable energy, solar hot water, a big battery for storing energy, living on tank water, growing as much of our own food as possible (hard during a drought), hybrid car, etc etc, however, I am also doing my best to help this dysfunctional society make an urgent transition to the Symbiocene … the era where humans re-integrate with nature. For example, I use Facebook to highlight the role of FB in destroying community and real human interaction. In my book, Earth Emotions, I criticise Amazon for its role in destroying cultural and ecological vitality … yet, my publisher uses Amazon to distribute the book! We have to live in a world we are trying our best to change. In that we have no choice. I support Extinction Rebellion (XR) in all that they are doing and despite Greta being used by all sorts of people (for and against Capitalism) she is worth strong support in a world that is mostly sleep walking. I write for academic and popular forums to argue for revolutionary change from the Anthropocene to the Symbiocene. I hope we are both doing our best to wake people up. There is a viable option for the future … but we have to create it! It is my hope that in creating a meme that champions a desirable future, the Symbiocene, all who are interested are being presented with “a viable option”. Rather than solastalgia and despair, the Symbiocene offers a degree of optimism and a home for positive Earth emotions. It seems to me that you are already in the Symbiocene. Welcome, you are not alone.

      Like

      1. Thanks, it’s good to feel a part of something good, and I do think that I am catching a whiff of positive change in the air. You mentioned Extinction Rebellion. Next week I am going to be a part of my first theatrical performance with a group of like minded people. We are Red Rebels. We will perform the 5 stages of grief then hope, action, victory, regeneration and, finally, joy. This will be as much a therapy to the players as it is to the audience. We all feel that these emotions are a part of working through the pain of solastalgia, hopefully to emerge with, as you say, a greater understanding and respect for ourselves and this beautiful plant in the Symbiocene.

        Liked by 1 person

  4. I’ve been living with your paper on Solastalgia for years now, and its takes a wildfire to bring a certain clarity to it. The profound grief is maddening and profound — the emotional scars may last for generations — but hopefully Holderlin was right — where the danger lies, salvation too is on the increase. Melancholia is a disorder experienced most deeply by creatives, so the recovery may also require a deeply creative response. I’ve started a poetry forum which embraces both grief and hope as the essential paired response to solastalgia. The fires in Australia prompted its existence. but everywhere there’s a report, a lament, a new leaf. This week’s verse challenge is Solastalgia. If you know of poets looking to express, pass the word on. Terraliben back atcha!

    Like

    1. I have shared your verse challenge on my Earth Emotions FB page. I hope it gets some attention. The dialectic of grief and hope is at the essence of solastalgia. To overcome feelings of powerlessness requires a full frontal challenge to those who currently hold power. Poetry, art and protest can do this. We need millions to punch the air yelling ‘terraliben’. We are all now compelled to play our part in the creation of the Symbiocene. Thank you for your support of my work.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Thanks Glenn — I’ve ordered a copy of Earth Emotions. The names you have come up I think will require some unpacking and exploration. Maybe we’ll do so challenges here taking up one earth emotion or another, asking for local experience around the globe on what they look and feel like. I’m sure the recent wildfire season in Australia has changed the register and tenor of them for you.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s